Aaron and I are trying to figure out where to go for our anniversary trip! Originally we had decided to go here, to the lovely Turks and Caicos Islands:


Two years ago, I was flying back from Puerto Rico and the captain got our attention to notify us we were flying over the Turks and Caicos Islands- at that moment I was attached. Even from 20,000+ ft in the air they were GORGEOUS. However, I've read hit or miss reviews for the all inclusive resorts on the islands.
So, we've also thought about going here, to St. Lucia:


I've heard amazing things about St. Lucia from a co-worker who honeymooned there. It's a distinct front runner.
Then there's also this place, Exuma (Bahamas):


This place is relatively new to the list, but I still like it.
I would love to go here, Bora Bora, but I just don't think Aaron would approve of the cost:


As you can see- they are all amazing and beautiful, and I'm truly blessed to get to go any of these places. But, I can't pick.
So, I need your help! What do you think- which tropical paradise would you chose? Or is there another I haven't even thought of that you can recommend? Let me know!